Xfactor 2008

Play Now

Neptune

Golden Oldie
Golden Oldie
Nov 19, 2003
1,473
9
175
Chester :P
i love this song, and she is good, 1 wrong note through it, but apart from that, it was brilliant. but the part she hit the wrong note u cud see like tiers in her eyes, so i think it wsa over looked tbh
 

Prai

Most Importantest
VIP
Sep 10, 2004
2,616
68
275
You cant really say theres a wrong note.. It depends how well the person sings the note. Its weird to explain though.
 

Neptune

Golden Oldie
Golden Oldie
Nov 19, 2003
1,473
9
175
Chester :P
You cant really say theres a wrong note.. It depends how well the person sings the note. Its weird to explain though.

i know, but she hit the note second time round, (im in music i know about the notes, and the emotions that effect it)
 

Prai

Most Importantest
VIP
Sep 10, 2004
2,616
68
275
What im saying is, a song has certain notes. By changing them or maybe not quite using the exact ones doesn't mean the songs a fail, just means there *Improv* in a way.
 

Neptune

Golden Oldie
Golden Oldie
Nov 19, 2003
1,473
9
175
Chester :P
but when u sing in the same octave as the auther of the song, to "change" 1 note in the song isnt exacly an improvement, changing it all to a octave higher/lower i will agree with, i didnt say she wasnt any good, i just 1 note not hit properly first time round, but u can see the emotion in her eyes, so it does kinda say "i didnt mean to hit it that high / low"