Guild Tax

[Varaka]

5% of gold gained from killing mobs goes automatically into the guild fund. With a record of how much each player has earned?

Getting tired of doing a whip round to kit members.

 

[ventus]

+1 I like this idea, think it would help guild relations.

 

[Pez]

what about guild leaders who abuse this and pocket the gold every night?

 

[<SOSO>]

what about guild leaders who abuse this and pocket the gold every night?

Exactly this. Guild leaders can exploit the **** out of it.

 

[Prai]

Here comes Hitler.

 

[Ralphy87]

Haha I like the idea

 

[littletommy]

make it so you cant withdraw from guild store?

 

[Lionsm!ght]

5% of gold gained from killing mobs goes automatically into the guild fund. With a record of how much each player has earned?

Getting tired of doing a whip round to kit members.

no thanks, other guild have different systems for building up guild funds, no need for an automatic tax.

 

[ventus]

Maybe make the tax optional on the members side

 

[KingCobra92]

Plenty of ways to do this without coding a feature into the game. If you can't manage this without an automated feature you're probably going to need to take a look at your leaders/guild friends

 

[WargodSius]

I recall a game I played once that had this feature. Was pretty cool. As a guild leader you could set the minimum (0% - 25%) and then individual users could simply change it themselves to a higher value if wanted. WAs good, but I'm not sure of the benefit in Mir, or this server.

 

[Varaka]

what about guild leaders who abuse this and pocket the gold every night?

Then you are in the wrong guild. Myself and other guild leaders are very active so we would be paying the most tax ( why i asked for a record of earnings from each player) . Guild funds would prob be used to kit members.

 

[mir2pion]

From other crystal servers, the problem was that adding gold to guild fund is anonymous, maximum you could do about that was you could mention it, brag about it in guild chat.
Those who would put in smaller amounts more frequently and always mention that in chat would look better than those who put in bigger chunks of gold less frequently.

 

[WargodSius]

From other crystal servers, the problem was that adding gold to guild fund is anonymous, maximum you could do about that was you could mention it, brag about it in guild chat.
Those who would put in smaller amounts more frequently and always mention that in chat would look better than those who put in bigger chunks of gold less frequently.

This has nothing to do with Mir, you are commenting on the nature of humans here. Don't see the real gameplay benefit of a log, but yeah I guess it would stop people lying.

 

[Kamikaze]

I actually mentioned this to Jamie yesterday, piss easy to code in, just got to make sure it doesn't tax the gold you receive from TM sales etc. Have a slider on guild page where you can set the tax band. 0-100% slider. Best way to play it would be to set it at 100% for guild hunts and then have it on whatever low figure you want the rest of the time. A great feature seen on a few servers, even had Seumus coding it in on our server in minutes.