Landscape I

Desolation Mir2 (Med Rate Server)

w00t84

Big Dick
Golden Oldie
May 25, 2004
1,690
10
174
Newcastle!
My first ever landscape, made purely in photoshop with no imported pictures/images. Tell me your thoughts and comments on improvements which could be made, and where...

LandscapeI.jpg
 

muffinpie

Golden Oldie
Golden Oldie
Jul 19, 2005
1,101
1
174
Dont like this at all w00t dont like the lines all over it and that sun dont look right maybe if u change that stuff it wil look better 6/10
 

w00t84

Big Dick
Golden Oldie
May 25, 2004
1,690
10
174
Newcastle!
Without the lands it looked bland and boring, I quite like all the things which you've said are bad. Must be about opinion, but hey I don't want your opinion anyway. About the only persons I don't care about ^.^
 

DayWalker™

Golden Oldie
Golden Oldie
Dec 11, 2004
761
1
103
Middlesbrough ! Smoggy!
I love it maybe edit the third hill from the left a bit, it looks a bit too sharpish make it look Hilly if you know what i mean.

8/10 with pointy hill

10/10 with rounder hill.

/Stan
 

w00t84

Big Dick
Golden Oldie
May 25, 2004
1,690
10
174
Newcastle!
Thanks for the comments guys, I appreciate it. It was my first ever try at something along these lines and I'm sure if I keep trying I will get better. Looking forward to posting my next one and getting your opinions, cheers :)
 

elohelMeight

Golden Oldie
Golden Oldie
Feb 8, 2004
2,965
10
125
Surrey
I like it all (even the use of dull colours for once). Im just not sure about the pointy hill type things. 7/10.

side note : whoever said 10/10, lets be serious. no image is ever 10/10 as that would make it 100% perfect and you wouldnt be able to do anything like move a line to make it that tad better :)
 

w00t84

Big Dick
Golden Oldie
May 25, 2004
1,690
10
174
Newcastle!
whoever said 10/10, lets be serious. no image is ever 10/10 as that would make it 100% perfect and you wouldnt be able to do anything like move a line to make it that tad better

How many times are people going to say this??

My answer to that is, Yes it can be perfect. People have different opinions to everyone else, I'm sure you've had something in life that was perfect to the precise second you needed it, but then someone came jogging past and said...
'This moment can no longer be perfect, as nothing is perfect...'
Hasn't happened to me, how about you?

All in all, what I'm trying to say is... Things can be perfect to some people, as we all have our own opinions on matters, so he may think this is perfect to the correct line or scratch. Clu3less, you really are a sheep and need to get your own head and stop following or copying everyone else.
 

elohelMeight

Golden Oldie
Golden Oldie
Feb 8, 2004
2,965
10
125
Surrey
how the fukc am i copying anyone esle? nobody else has stated what i said. so you get your head out from between your as$cheeks and stop being a fool. thnx
 

w00t84

Big Dick
Golden Oldie
May 25, 2004
1,690
10
174
Newcastle!
Everybody says it... It doesn't have to be said in my thread. As soon as JealY sees this he will back me up, as he started the 'Nothing can be perfect' phase. I think.
 

EvilGoku

Golden Oldie
Golden Oldie
Apr 28, 2005
526
0
102
Brighton
Welll all i can say about this peice is that... Its t3h sex... and well line or no line illl give this 11/10 it reminds me of some cartoonish thing... erm cant remember the cartoonist but i love the effect :D

You will go far young jedi knight



Tx, owns 11/10 counts get off my back sucka
 

JealY

LOMCN VIP
VIP
Nov 28, 2004
5,357
56
335
England
i don't like that, it doesn't look like a landscape to me, and the hill-type-things look too tacky

4/10

/J34lY
 

w00t84

Big Dick
Golden Oldie
May 25, 2004
1,690
10
174
Newcastle!
Thanks for the rest of your views. I believe this piece is a 'Hate it, or love it' because I've had many views of different standards, some like it some don't.

Thanks for your views Goku, means alot that you like it. You're a brilliant designer yourself. Thanks for your comment also JealY, I agree the hills look tacky, was the hardest part >.< Not easy to do hills, if anybody could show me a better way I'd be happy to try it :)
 

elohelMeight

Golden Oldie
Golden Oldie
Feb 8, 2004
2,965
10
125
Surrey
People have stated what to do mate. Just make them so that they aren't so sharp. Make them so where the straight lines meet they are a bit more curved and also curv them a bit on the point of each hill :) Also, the hill on the right is the worst i'd say mate. Try and change this one so it's like the rest and not just 2 straight lines :)
 

EvilGoku

Golden Oldie
Golden Oldie
Apr 28, 2005
526
0
102
Brighton
But the jagged effect makes the peice imo...
its all about personal pereference if its all smooth it looses its unique touch



Tx, rawr
 

elohelMeight

Golden Oldie
Golden Oldie
Feb 8, 2004
2,965
10
125
Surrey
well, at the end of the day. if steish likes it he will have to keep it this way. as if he modifies it people wont like it and people will like it... so it's steish's choice :) as he said, it's an either love it or hate it piece