Singature wanted please.
- Thread starter Eskimo
- Start date
- May 7, 2003
- 1,341
- 1
- 244
- 295
Pyraines looks like he's just ripped a poorly compressed picture of a dead seal, added a boarder to it and wrote 'Eskimo' in text thats nothing special. You seem to have your head so far up your ass pyraine, you can taste your own stomach acid.
Turin's isn't great either, but at least it looks like he's put some effort into it, and it's certainly a better attempt than pyraines. Turin, everything looks a little big on your signature, the size, the render, the alpha bar, even the text to some extent. I think you should also revise your placement. Maybe after you've made some key modifications I'll give you the tumbs up.
<3 me
Turin's isn't great either, but at least it looks like he's put some effort into it, and it's certainly a better attempt than pyraines. Turin, everything looks a little big on your signature, the size, the render, the alpha bar, even the text to some extent. I think you should also revise your placement. Maybe after you've made some key modifications I'll give you the tumbs up.
<3 me
oh look 3 people who have commented on my signature negatively, DayWalker, Lyrical G and Gimpasauraus, DayWalker and lyricalG both tried flaming me in the past and Gimpasaurus is my mortal enemy
but yes this was originally a joke, i never thought a dead seal would be accepted, but i don't care how simple it is to make, lyricalg, your signature is incredibly easy to make, but it still looks good, no matter how hard turins was to make, the end result is terrible, and i've seen him do ok stuff and it's bad, just look at the quality, the fonts, the sprite, the background, the size of the bar going across, there are numerous points which make it a pile of poo, i don't want mine to be chosen, it's an offensive joke, but either way i don't see how you can think the one turin made is better
turin if you want constructive critiscm, read my last paragraph, and you couldn't recreate it in MS paint if i gave you the original picture, i had to do alot of cloning to get the dimensions right without messing up the quality of the original picture as it was already bad enough, also i'd like to see you do a nice drop shadow in paint
but yes this was originally a joke, i never thought a dead seal would be accepted, but i don't care how simple it is to make, lyricalg, your signature is incredibly easy to make, but it still looks good, no matter how hard turins was to make, the end result is terrible, and i've seen him do ok stuff and it's bad, just look at the quality, the fonts, the sprite, the background, the size of the bar going across, there are numerous points which make it a pile of poo, i don't want mine to be chosen, it's an offensive joke, but either way i don't see how you can think the one turin made is better
turin if you want constructive critiscm, read my last paragraph, and you couldn't recreate it in MS paint if i gave you the original picture, i had to do alot of cloning to get the dimensions right without messing up the quality of the original picture as it was already bad enough, also i'd like to see you do a nice drop shadow in paint
Lyrical G said:
unch: Thanks man for the advice I'll implement it when I got time and report back punk: + your vector siggy rules.ps -
Pyraine said:oh look 3 people who have commented on my signature negatively, DayWalker, Lyrical G and Gimpasauraus, DayWalker and lyricalG both tried flaming me in the past and Gimpasaurus is my mortal enemy
but yes this was originally a joke, i never thought a dead seal would be accepted, but i don't care how simple it is to make, lyricalg, your signature is incredibly easy to make, but it still looks good, no matter how hard turins was to make, the end result is terrible, and i've seen him do ok stuff and it's bad, just look at the quality, the fonts, the sprite, the background, the size of the bar going across, there are numerous points which make it a pile of poo, i don't want mine to be chosen, it's an offensive joke, but either way i don't see how you can think the one turin made is better
turin if you want constructive critiscm, read my last paragraph, and you couldn't recreate it in MS paint if i gave you the original picture, i had to do alot of cloning to get the dimensions right without messing up the quality of the original picture as it was already bad enough, also i'd like to see you do a nice drop shadow in paint
lol I was being sarcastic, calm down.
Last edited:
- May 7, 2003
- 1,341
- 1
- 244
- 295
Anyones signature is easy to make, but it's hard to make something original. I could remake this one in a matter of minutes dispite the fact it took me about 45mins to create. You see, I dont spend ages packing as much as possible into an over populated canvas, I like to make something simple, and make little tweak after tweat untill I feel its just right. How easy it is to make is irellivant, what is however, is how it is presented. Don't try to compare myself to you, we operate in very different ways.Pyraine said:oh look 3 people who have commented on my signature negatively, DayWalker, Lyrical G and Gimpasauraus, DayWalker and lyricalG both tried flaming me in the past and Gimpasaurus is my mortal enemy
but yes this was originally a joke, i never thought a dead seal would be accepted, but i don't care how simple it is to make, lyricalg, your signature is incredibly easy to make, but it still looks good, no matter how hard turins was to make, the end result is terrible, and i've seen him do ok stuff and it's bad, just look at the quality, the fonts, the sprite, the background, the size of the bar going across, there are numerous points which make it a pile of poo, i don't want mine to be chosen, it's an offensive joke, but either way i don't see how you can think the one turin made is better
turin if you want constructive critiscm, read my last paragraph, and you couldn't recreate it in MS paint if i gave you the original picture, i had to do alot of cloning to get the dimensions right without messing up the quality of the original picture as it was already bad enough, also i'd like to see you do a nice drop shadow in paint
It's nothing personal that I decided to give you negative feedback, but firstly I didn't like your attempt, and then you made the arogant statement to Turin (Who actually made the effort to try and create Eskimo a serious signature) that 'Mines better than yours', uncalled for? (or another one of your many backfiring jokes). I don't want to turn this thread into a flame war, so i'll leave it at that.
Lyrical G said:
well your first paragraph backs up my whole point so thanks lyrical
and even though mine is a joke and turins is serious i still think mine looks better as a signature, despite the effort, that may or may not be an arrogant opinion but it's my opinion none the less, and i haven't really flamed anyone yet, and i wasn't offended by what you said, so i don't see a flame war starting just yet
- Jul 20, 2004
- 5,258
- 3
- 275
The reason i commented negatively on the signature you made, is most certainly NOT because i don't like you, or vice versa. I really couldn't care less who made the signature, but it's my opinion that having a clubbed seal as a signature is plain stupid.Pyraine said:oh look 3 people who have commented on my signature negatively, DayWalker, Lyrical G and Gimpasauraus, DayWalker and lyricalG both tried flaming me in the past and Gimpasaurus is my mortal enemy
but yes this was originally a joke, i never thought a dead seal would be accepted, but i don't care how simple it is to make, lyricalg, your signature is incredibly easy to make, but it still looks good, no matter how hard turins was to make, the end result is terrible, and i've seen him do ok stuff and it's bad, just look at the quality, the fonts, the sprite, the background, the size of the bar going across, there are numerous points which make it a pile of poo, i don't want mine to be chosen, it's an offensive joke, but either way i don't see how you can think the one turin made is better
turin if you want constructive critiscm, read my last paragraph, and you couldn't recreate it in MS paint if i gave you the original picture, i had to do alot of cloning to get the dimensions right without messing up the quality of the original picture as it was already bad enough, also i'd like to see you do a nice drop shadow in paint
shush now mortal enemy before i banish thee to the nether realm
the signature was a joke, the timing was perfect, my friend sent me a few pictures of clubbed seals over msn, and a person with a name of the people who do the clubbing was posting asking for a signature, i could not resist
the signature was a joke, the timing was perfect, my friend sent me a few pictures of clubbed seals over msn, and a person with a name of the people who do the clubbing was posting asking for a signature, i could not resist
Pyraine said:
Even if it was a joke and you did hardly anything to it, it still looks nice. And before people come running to me saying but what about Turin's signature he done for you? I did say in a previous post that although I probably wouldn't use it, and I didn't exactly like it, he had put the time and effort in to make it. Even if it was 4am lol. So I am not saying anyone's is "poop".
oh don't get me wrong, it was a joke, it doesn't mean i did hardly anything to it, i spent alot of time cloning
i don't care how much time and effort turin put into his, regardless of the one i made, it's not a good signature
that's the problem with this forum, everyone who posts their work expects positive feedback, always and in most cases they get positive feedback it's rediculous
i don't care how much time and effort turin put into his, regardless of the one i made, it's not a good signature
that's the problem with this forum, everyone who posts their work expects positive feedback, always and in most cases they get positive feedback it's rediculous
Pyraine said:
Sorry you got me wrong... I didn't put it up for criticism in the first place, but I really don't care for unconstructive feedback, like "Mines better na na na!". Prefer if you could point out the problem like Lyrical G did so I could improve it. Please just stop flaming each other so we can do what the thread requests :agree:
Ty for the feedback
Turin.