Critical Damage added items

Mu online season 21 - grand opening

Jicaa

Pooslice
Golden Oldie
Jul 9, 2003
2,386
36
184
Just curious if when added it is supposed to be 1% and not just 1 critical damage, cause well 1% is completely pointless, whereas a full 1 would actually be worth looking into :)
 

Turrican

LOMCN Member
Untrusted Member
Dedicated Member
Jul 24, 2012
1,140
18
100
UK
Just curious if when added it is supposed to be 1% and not just 1 critical damage, cause well 1% is completely pointless, whereas a full 1 would actually be worth looking into :)
When it was first added i'm sure it was similar to that of luck , 10% increments per 1.

so with crit+1, your max hit would be 110 rather than 100.

this may of been changed since though.
 

Jicaa

Pooslice
Golden Oldie
Jul 9, 2003
2,386
36
184
When it was first added i'm sure it was similar to that of luck , 10% increments per 1.

so with crit+1, your max hit would be 110 rather than 100.

this may of been changed since though.

I believe it is 10% per 1, but when an added item drops with it on its only 1%, seems very poor for something that rarely shows on added items.
 

Attachments

  • critpoo.png
    critpoo.png
    61.8 KB · Views: 86

Turrican

LOMCN Member
Untrusted Member
Dedicated Member
Jul 24, 2012
1,140
18
100
UK
Crit damage was only intended to work with archer, items dropping with crit damage would appear to be a bug, no items should drop with crit afaik.
 

Jicaa

Pooslice
Golden Oldie
Jul 9, 2003
2,386
36
184
If it isn't coded into the class then it shouldn't matter?

I don't see it as a bug :D I see it as a opportunity for archer's to go a more accuracy/crit based build rather than purely stacking DC. Well I would love that choice :D
 

ILovePie:D

Golden Oldie
Golden Oldie
Apr 22, 2003
2,260
15
225
I believe it is 10% per 1, but when an added item drops with it on its only 1%, seems very poor for something that rarely shows on added items.

So, an archer with a Ruthless Bow (Crit+3) and Barbed Black Arrows (Crit+3) is already hitting +60% .. do you feel that the items should stack another 10% each, or 1% on top of these, is already plenty?
 

Jicaa

Pooslice
Golden Oldie
Jul 9, 2003
2,386
36
184
So, an archer with a Ruthless Bow (Crit+3) and Barbed Black Arrows (Crit+3) is already hitting +60% .. do you feel that the items should stack another 10% each, or 1% on top of these, is already plenty?

Well 1% is completely pointless, especially seeing as you hardly ever see crit damage added items. I actually feel like archer do some great damage, was just giving an opinion on a completely redundant item, if I was to crit 100% of the time I would actually rate it ok enough, but you don't, so it's actual value is a lot lower than 1 dc. 1 DC added on items is seen a lot more than crit damage.
 

Turrican

LOMCN Member
Untrusted Member
Dedicated Member
Jul 24, 2012
1,140
18
100
UK
If it isn't coded into the class then it shouldn't matter?

I don't see it as a bug :D I see it as a opportunity for archer's to go a more accuracy/crit based build rather than purely stacking DC. Well I would love that choice :D

archers can already go crit/acc route, acc increases crit for archers.

Items dropping with crit just enables other classes to use the stat, while this may not be a big issue, the crit % stat is a bug probably left over from apple code (hence why archer uses +1 and that item stat uses %) which would need testing to make sure its not providing buffs in other areas.

no idea if this crit % even works with spells which is what archer abilitys are based off. its probably a melee version of crit, and last thing classes like warrior/sin with a.speed 6+ and luck 5-7 - dc100+ need is a crit advantage which other casters cant get.
 
Last edited:

ILovePie:D

Golden Oldie
Golden Oldie
Apr 22, 2003
2,260
15
225
Well 1% is completely pointless, especially seeing as you hardly ever see crit damage added items. I actually feel like archer do some great damage, was just giving an opinion on a completely redundant item, if I was to crit 100% of the time I would actually rate it ok enough, but you don't, so it's actual value is a lot lower than 1 dc. 1 DC added on items is seen a lot more than crit damage.

But you're still able to 3 DC on top of this, so as well as 60% increase off weapon and arrows, you could spec a few other items with it, possible 65%? With extra DC on top.

It's a bonus stat, like crystal armour reflecting a hit.
 

Jicaa

Pooslice
Golden Oldie
Jul 9, 2003
2,386
36
184
But you're still able to 3 DC on top of this, so as well as 60% increase off weapon and arrows, you could spec a few other items with it, possible 65%? With extra DC on top.

It's a bonus stat, like crystal armour reflecting a hit.

Fair enough, I would rather just gem a KnightBracelet though, if it was say 3% then I would of been tempted.
 

kickey

LOMCN Veteran
Veteran
Jun 5, 2010
686
1
104
Fair enough, I would rather just gem a KnightBracelet though, if it was say 3% then I would of been tempted.

3% = 30% more damage when u crit.

you honestly can not be serious right now.....

archers have plenty of crit..

and as for you not thinking +1% (10%) more damage on 1 item isn't worth you time to gem it???

i guess that just shows what level off a player you are.

(p.s hope turrican is right. archers have no need for more damage)
 

Jicaa

Pooslice
Golden Oldie
Jul 9, 2003
2,386
36
184
3% = 30% more damage when u crit.

you honestly can not be serious right now.....

archers have plenty of crit..

and as for you not thinking +1% (10%) more damage on 1 item isn't worth you time to gem it???

i guess that just shows what level off a player you are.

(p.s hope turrican is right. archers have no need for more damage)

Ermmm can you read? It says 1%(1%), that's 1% not 10%.

3 Critical Damage is 30% damage, 3% Critical Damage is 3% Critical Damage.
 

kickey

LOMCN Veteran
Veteran
Jun 5, 2010
686
1
104
When it was first added i'm sure it was similar to that of luck , 10% increments per 1.

so with crit+1, your max hit would be 110 rather than 100.

this may of been changed since though.

mayb mis-read this.

but if its a bug then surely you would be explioting by using it making this thread pointless :P
 
Last edited:

Jicaa

Pooslice
Golden Oldie
Jul 9, 2003
2,386
36
184
mayb mis-read this.

but if its a bug then surely you would be explioting by using it making this thread pointless :P

as he said crit+1, not crit+1% they are completely different values

1% is not equal to 10%

Probably sounded like a douche there, kind of misinterpreted what you put lol, plus the fact I didn't sleep properly and have been at work all day :RpS_sleep:
 
Last edited:

rainstone

LOMCN Veteran
Veteran
Feb 10, 2014
770
9
79
I would like to find out what is the function of this items...You can sell it too me, although it seems useless...
as he said crit+1, not crit+1% they are completely different values

1% is not equal to 10%

Probably sounded like a douche there, kind of misinterpreted what you put lol, plus the fact I didn't sleep properly and have been at work all day :RpS_sleep: