First of this style

[Flame]

hey guys this is my first attempt at this style siggy im still very noob to photoshop anyways tell me wot u think and how i could improve?

Thx

 

[Ragnar]

The font is a total no-no.
Signatures without a border are a total no-no (apart from some exceptions).
The picture in total is actually pretty good (is it tutorialized?).

 

[AriaQ]

I like everything exsept the font and as Ingel said, all sinatures need a little boarder.

 

[Flame]

i followed a tutorial about those type of siggys Grunge i believe it is ? lol but no i made that 100% myself hmm ill try diff font and add a border then post bak my results thx for ur opinions guys ill post back soon .

EDIT:- why waste a post? :P

anyways i edited it a bit but im well tired gonna go bed now actually aint slept all night and day ill edit it more 2moro when i cba lol it sux i cudnt find a font and done an ok border i suppose...

 

[anto]

It seems like the picture is screeming in pain because of the font, CHANGE IT!!!

 

[AriaQ]

I still disslikie the font. Maybe a little blending in to the img.

alot better then b4, and again n1

 

[anto]

Change the font to arial black and on each letter lower it's opacity to less than the one before.

 

[Pyraine]

I THINK IT HAS POTENTIAL

but needs a total makeover

desaturate it (ctrl + shift + u)

and give it a new life by pressing ctrl + u and then ticking colorize and playing around till you get a color you like.

Also you insist on using these far out fonts, well the only way you're gonna make one of them look good is possibly, by while you still have the font selected, at the top where there should be a drop down box with a list like crisp, strong etc. set that to smooth, then give it an effect, but be subtle, like an outer glow that is similar to the color of the rest of the picture and maybe a very slight emboss or a very slight drop shadow and for the love of christ don't make it baby blue, stick to like, black.

Also, a 1 pixel black border is fine and nicer than this red thing.

I personally think if you follow that you will have a very signature

 

[Flame]

i think maybe its better? lol your opinions not mine but i think its alot better i still dnt think ive gotten away with the text tho lets see

 

[Wittin]

Actually, the text looks a hell of alot better, would be nicer a few sizes smaller. I do agree, it looks a hell of alot better colorized!

I would give it a decent 7 out of ten after you've cleaned up the text a little

 

[XeroX]

yeah its quite good now m8. id give an easy 8/10

 

[Ragnar]

i think maybe its better? lol your opinions not mine but i think its alot better i still dnt think ive gotten away with the text tho lets see

If you would get a nice simple font for it i would give you a 9/10.

 

[Flame]

Better text ppl?

 

[Wittin]

Better text ppl?

I didnt think the font you had (on the original colorized version) was all that bad (seemed to match the image), just needed making smaller. However that font's fine, good job.

 

[Ragnar]

Better text ppl?

A lot better IMO. only i think it could use some "hardening" if you know what i mean, maybe make it darker.

 

[Wittin]

Now stick the thing in the space for signatures provided by vBulletin for you.

 

[Flame]

wheres that Lyrical? :P and i dnt know wot Hardening means tbh im still noob hehe

 

[Ragnar]

wheres that Lyrical? :P and i dnt know wot Hardening means tbh im still noob hehe

He means put it as your signature. And i basically ment that maybe try making the font darker.

 

[SkyDragon]

Better text ppl?

sexy m8 , the text flows nice with the sig and dont stand out 2 much

 

[Eskimo]

I don't like the thick border, but otherwise nice. The plain simple font looks much better than the other, the other looked too... too empty? Just didn't match the image. With a simple 1px white border, I would give it 8/10.